Election Reflections
The vote is in. Hillary won. Oops, no she didn’t. Donald did. Electorally that is. Such is our system. This post is a reflection on how that system is working.
The Politics of Personality
The election was a battle of personas, not policies, and on that score Trump had more appeal across a wider geographic area giving him the electoral victory. Forget how the system works for a moment, and you can predict that a presidential election will be won by the person with the stronger popular appeal as a person (e.g., Bush vs. Gore, Obama vs. Romney). It’s captured in the question of "Who would you rather have a beer with?" Clinton was rational and restrained. Trump was erratic and bombastic. Trump got more than twice as much free press coverage as Clinton by being Trump. His energy captured the feelings of his followers. Despite being a billionaire, people felt he understood them better than Clinton.
Feelings - Winners and Losers
There is a mix of satisfaction and angst in the country.
Satisfaction is from the Trump supporters who think they got what they voted for. They seem happy to have sent the message that politics as usual is no longer popular. They also sent the message that white, lower and middle class urban and rural America still exists. Its power has not been replaced yet by a multi-cultural, bi coastal, and urban power base. Tired of a media that has overlooked them in favor of minority groups from blacks, to Hispanics, to the LGBTQ community, they appeared from behind the corn rows, coal mines, and car assembly lines and went to the polls.
Angst comes from everyone else who is afraid of what they think they got. Hillary Clinton wasn’t Bill Clinton. She lacked the charisma and the political savvy to ingratiate herself to enough of the voters outside of the urban and coastal Democratic strongholds. She could not pull the same level of support from the nonwhite community as a woman that Barack Obama did as a black man. Even the gender card did not seem to play in her favor as strongly as the black card did for Obama. Getting people to vote for her because she wasn’t Donald Trump was not enough either, although many people undoubtedly voted for her because of whom she was and what she stood for. And finally, her tendency toward secrecy and skirting the rules that gave rise to her email server problems confirmed that she was at least suspect, if not downright untrustworthy. The tiger just couldn’t change the stripes on her pant’s suit.
This was an election that a majority of people were unhappy with from the start. They did not like either candidate. Now that one has won, he can’t expect to be welcomed to the office with open arms, particularly after the nasty, character attacking campaign that was waged by both sides. When you sling mud in the campaign, you end up with some of it sticking around afterward. The fact the electoral and popular vote did not align only makes matters worse. This was going to be a bitter win/lose election where the losers on either side would not shrug it off easily. If Clinton had won, the streets would probably have Trump supporters marching down them.
Never mind the temporary "make nice" rhetoric from the Democrats and fellow Republicans, there is enough animosity around Donald Trump for partisan politics to obstruct his agenda in the same fashion Obama suffered. Remember that Obama had a Democratic Congress for his first two years and then was stonewalled for the next six by a Republican one. The same thing is likely to happen with Trump if the Democrats prevail in the midterm elections. Bill and Hillary Clinton aren’t going to fade into the political woodwork and that spells trouble for Trump.
The Electoral College
So long as the national popular vote tally and the Electoral College results produce the same winner, few people care about this aspect of our system of government. When they don’t line up, it gives fuel to an argument about its contemporary relevance. That’s what we have now.
To appreciate the Electoral College requires a journey back in time to the drafting of the Constitution. It was drafted in the summer of 1787 at the Constitution Convention in Philadelphia and was ratified in May of 1790. Included in it was the provision for the Electoral College (later amended with the 12th Amendment in 1800). Why not just make the election a popular vote and leave it at that? Obviously the framers had something on their minds.
As we consider that, keep in mind there were differing opinions about the power of the states vs. the federal government, about slavery, about taxation, and about a standing army vs. state militias. There were no political parties yet, but the different philosophies of government from which they would arise were firmly in place. The views of Jefferson and Hamilton would come to be the positions around which the two-party system would emerge.
The writing of the Constitution was an experiment in creating a new form of government. It entailed a huge risk, a leap of faith that people could wisely govern themselves. People deserved freedom, but could they handle the responsibility? In addition, the states were jockeying for influence in a federal government. Prior to this time, they were independent colonies or separate states bound by the looser Articles of Confederation. The Constitution was a replacement for the Articles which had proved inadequate for sustaining a unified government.
A big problem was how much representation each state would have in the federal government. The northern states were more trade and commerce focused, the southern ones were agricultural. Slavery was legal in seven states from New York southward (excluding Pennsylvania). The South had the greater number of actual slaves. But, slaves weren’t citizens so the South was at a disadvantage when counting population for representation. Getting all the states into a union required compromises based on political necessity at the expense of moral rectitude. The greater good was the union, the evil it took to achieve it was leaving slavery in place and counting slaves as 3/5 of a person for representation in Congress.
It is essential to note that the issue of slavery and representation was not focused on the creation of the Electoral College. It was focused on the creation of the Senate and the House of Representatives. To assert that slavery was the reason for the Electoral College is to overlook the fact that the College is based on the Congress, not the other way around. Once the basis for allocating seats in Congress was settled, it provided a starting point for how to configure the Electoral College. Balancing the states’ power in picking a president was more easily dealt with by using a previously agreed upon balance of representation.
Why do that? The small states were afraid of being overpowered by the large states. Who were those small states? The ones in the South? No. In the fourth U.S. Congress, the five smallest states based on the number of representatives in the House were: Delaware (1), Vermont (2), Rhode Island (2), New Hampshire (4) and New Jersey (5). By these states having the same number of senators as the larger states, their relative power was protected. The process was a way to balance power based on population (the House) with power based on statehood (the Senate). While counting slaves was a way to increase the relative power of the Southern states in the House which made them ‘less small’ population-wise, there were five Northern states that needed the same protection.
We see a similar dynamic today when the Democrats typically win seats on the heavily populated coasts and urban centers, while the Republicans win the wide geographic area of the nation’s center. How do you balance geography and population? How do you balance the equality of states with each other as independent states, yet take into account the inequality of populations? The answer is the Senate and the House of Representatives - the U.S. Congress. It is from that structure the Electoral College derives. If the Congress is a fair and workable arrangement, then so is the College. If the College is not, then neither is the Congress.
But there’s more to the story. Here we return to the question of whether the new leaders could trust the judgment of the people. Not all of them were convinced. Some feared that the people could be led astray by a demagogue or even by a foreign power such as England or France. By inserting the Electoral College between the popular vote and the final appointing of a president, the system gained a check and balance against a democracy run amok. The framers went so far as to spell out that government officials could not become electors as a way to prevent tainting the College. Over the years, their intent for an independent but faithful elector has slowly been morphed into one where electors are political party functionaries. That fact virtually guarantees that an elector will not change his/her vote from the results in his/her state.
In all the elections that have been held, there are only 157 "faithless electors" who did not follow their state votes. Seventy-one of them changed votes when a candidate died between the election and the voting of the electors - they wouldn’t vote for a dead man! Since 1900, only ten electors have not adhered to the state results and in no case did it alter the electoral college outcome. There was a big dust-up for the election of Rutherford B. Hayes vs. Tilden in 1876 when both parties in four states claimed victory. That left 20 electoral votes in limbo - just enough to tip the balance from Tilden to Hayes. The parties brokered a deal that put Hayes in office. The problem was not with the Electoral College, it was with the election results themselves in four states.
Today, in a presidential election in Tennessee, you do not actually vote for the candidate even though his/her name is on the ballot. You actually vote for the electors the candidate has picked to represent him/her in the Electoral College. Those electors are hand-picked party members whose loyalty to the candidate should be unquestionable. They are not a group of independent-minded citizens as was probably the intent of the framers of the Constitution. As a result, it is highly unlikely the Electoral College vote would ever deviate from the state results (national results are different).
Furthermore, the system has become a "winner-take-all" electoral vote in all states but two. This has the effect of exaggerating the electoral vote margin of victory compared to the popular vote in each state and the nation. It also created this year’s conundrum of the electoral winner and the popular winner being different. Once a candidate wins a state, even by the thinnest of margins, running up a large popular vote in the state is meaningless as far an electoral victory is concerned. A candidate’s strategy must be to capture states, not just votes. If each state allocated its electoral votes based on its popular vote (as do Maine and Nebraska), the electoral and popular votes would align more closely.
So is the Electoral College outdated and should it be dropped in favor of a national popular vote winner? That is the same argument the framers of the Constitution faced more than 200 years ago. The reasons for and against remain pretty much the same and the right answer just as elusive. Each choice has its own inherent problems. It is wise to keep in mind that changing a system to solve one apparent problem can give rise to new problems that could not appear in the old system. This is especially true when removing a check in a check-and-balance system.
Hillary Clinton has won the popular vote with a margin of about 670,000 votes out of 121,410,000 as of mid November - that’s a margin of one half of one percent (0.55%). If the will of the people (as evidenced by the popular vote) determined the outcome, we would have Hillary Clinton as president-elect (ditto for Al Gore in 2000). Democrats seem to be on the losing side of the Electoral College system. There is no arguing that. But, an election is like a battle. One side can field more troops, but if they are deployed in the wrong locations, a smaller force can overcome them. What Clinton achieved in numbers, she lost to strategy.
For those people lamenting the unfairness of the Electoral College, it might be well to ask these questions.
1. If the outcome of this election were reversed, and Trump had the popular vote and Clinton the Electoral win, what would their respective supporters be saying? Would Democrats still want the popular vote to prevail? Would Trump supporters be shouting "Rigged?"
2. Should Congress be reconfigured because it uses the same structure?
3. Should the Democratic party eliminate "super delegates?" These delegates (15% of the total at the DNC) skewed the nomination in favor of Clinton at the expense of Bernie Sanders.
It is difficult to imagine denouncing the Electoral College as a misrepresentation without doing the same thing for the Democratic party’s nominating process. The super delegates gave the Democrats a safety valve to pick an establishment candidate. The Republicans lacked such a feature - and look what happened. It’s not enough to look at just the election, we must also look at the process that produces the candidates that run in the election. That process seems sadly flawed in both parties judging by the rampant distaste for both candidates.
To wrap up the Electoral College debate, let’s note that the election process is clearly spelled out. Everyone knows the rules whether they like them or not. So to win, you play by the rules. Changing the rules is another story, and to do that requires one of three things:
A. Amend the Constitution.
B. Have each state allocate its electoral votes on the basis of that the state’s popular vote.
C. Have all states sign a compact that requires their electors to vote for the winner of the national popular vote. Some states have already done this with the provision it only goes into effect when all states sign it.
Would changing the Electoral College really matter? When the margin of popular vote victory is very small, it means that both candidates have nearly equal claim to govern. What mathematically may look like a clear cut win, is realistically not much of a win at all. This is one reason the nation remains so politically divided and resentful. When you lose by a large margin, you know you are licked. When you lose by a small one, you feel like you are ticked. Sports victories by one point and political victories by one point are not the same at all.
If you want to change the Electoral College, write to your representative in your state legislature.
The Candidate Conundrum
As a last observation on the election, we should look at how we got the two candidates we did, why we did not have better ones to choose from, and how one so unpopular got elected. (That’s not just a personal view, polling indicated widespread unfavorability ratings for both Trump and Clinton.)
The blame rests in several places. The primary one is "we, the people." The second one is "the media." The third one is the two major parties.
It takes someone with an exceptionally large and durable ego to withstand running for president. Why is that? It is caused by the opposition digging up as much dirt as possible to discourage voters from choosing the other candidate; by the people being willing to listen to and react to that dirt; by the media being accomplices in dishing the dirt out to the public and even digging some of it up themselves. That is not to say that we should not know about the relevant negatives of candidates. However, that seems to be all we know anymore.
Discussions of policy and philosophy of governing were largely absent from this election. Most of what occurred was a discussion of how unfit the other candidate was. While that’s not new to presidential politics, it reached a contemporary low in this election. "I Like Ike" and "Jail the Bitch" are poles apart. Wedged in between the negative narrative were unrealistic promises for programs that would inflate the national debt way beyond its current level - true for both candidates. As the voting public, we were short changed.
The press has an obligation to inform the electorate, not merely pass on the propaganda of each campaign. Sadly, the press has fallen prey to something called "false equivalency" where any point of view is treated with nearly equal credibility, no matter how irrational it may be. While the press may feel it is up to the opposition to provide the counter point, the press itself must play the role of a "prudent man" in its reporting. Instead, it panders to a population whose taste for the hype of reality TV is spoiling its appetite for real information.
How did we get to this place? We can blame the dumbing down of America on an antiquated and overburdened educational system that graduates ignorant voters. The greatest protection for a democracy is a well educated and well informed electorate. We are failing on both counts. When ignorant, ill-informed people vote, the results reflect it. Neither party has a monopoly on this. There are red-neck Republicans and dumb Democrats. The answer is not to restrict who votes, but to create voters who can better assess the candidates, their platforms, and their promises. It is a press that fact checks and sorts what it prints, not based on partisan views, but on what is factually and logically correct. A strong editorial page and op ed columns go hand-in-hand with good journalism in the news section. BS needs called out, not shoveled out. If we are to make America great again, this is the place to start. The responsibility to make a judicious choice is connected to the right to make that choice - to vote.
Demise of the Two-Party System
Finally, we are coming to the point in American politics where the two-party system is beginning to fall apart. Europe is already there. Our country is splitting along numerous lines whether they are based on class, race, generation, income, education, or geography. The tents of the parties can no longer cover them all. The right is too far right, the left too far left and the middle left uncovered as the right and left pull the fabric of their parties’ tents away from the center. There is ample room for a more central-thinking, compromise-governing party to arise. Instead of other parties like the Libertarian and Green parties appearing farther on the fringe of right and left, the time is ripe for a party in the middle that is fiscally responsible and socially tolerant. All it lacks is a charismatic leader to emerge. Until that happens, and even afterward, the two main parties will continue to splinter internally and fail to govern effectively even when they hold a majority of Congress. This is because the "majority" itself is no longer homogenous. Just ask John Boehner.
With the parties falling apart, negative campaigning the force-de-jour, a hesitant press, and an educationally eroded electorate, we can only expect government to get worse with each future election. Potentially good candidates will not apply because of the personal cost to themselves and their families of being scrutinized and criticized for every character flaw, mistake, or rethought position during their lifetimes. All of this is now magnified through the unprecedented help of unrestrained, fact-free, social media. The parties will present us with poor alternatives, the press will feed us titillating but irrelevant information, and everyone will reinforce his/her preconceptions by listening to the media outlet that offers reassurance they are right.
If this sounds pessimistic, it is.
Tuesday, November 15, 2016
Monday, September 26, 2016
Presidential Election - 2016 - First Debate Prologue
Tonight there will be promises by each candidate on what he or she will single-handedly do to make our country great again together (that’s a bipartisan combination). The way government works is a bit more complicated. While we all know this, I wanted to add some personal perspective to the mix.
Bills that will become laws originate in the House of Representatives. If passed, they move to the Senate for additional approval. If passed by the Senate, they go to the President for signature or veto. If signed into law, they are subject to challenge by affected parties who can pursue the case all the way to the Supreme court where the law can be upheld or struck down. If vetoed, the veto can be overridden by the Congress if two-thirds of both houses support the legislation. Nowhere in this process does the President have single-handed control.
Presidents, however, do exert a powerful influence. FDR did it in the depression through legislation and his "fireside chats." Reagan reinvigorated America’s sense of pride after Nixon and Carter. Bush gave us the Iraq war. Obama championed the Affordable Care Act. In the cases of FDR and Obama, Congress cooperated with the necessary legislation. This often requires that the same party control both the Office of the President and both houses of Congress (which Obama had for his first two years). Lacking control of both branches, it requires a sensible President and enough sensible members of Congress to collaborate and negotiate effective legislation - something that has been in seemingly short supply of late.
What’s this mean for the current election? Several things. If the new President and the Congress are the same party, odds of the President doing what he or she wants are higher - some of what we hear tonight may come true. Without that, gridlock may limit the President to "executive orders" (Obama’s predicament for the last six years). The new president will have the power, with the consent of Congress, to appoint new Supreme Court justices whose personal leanings will affect the interpretation and enforcement of laws for many future years. However, here again, there is a check and balance between the executive and legislative branches. The framers of the Constitution gave us a robust system for governance. All it requires are the right players. That’s why our votes matter so much, because we pick the team, not just the quarterback.
While the candidates will be looking for our votes, we must remember that much of the control of our government rests with both houses of Congress. It behoves us to scrutinize whom we will elect to Congress this year and in future years. Each individual choice for a representative or senator may not look significant, but collectively it is. Real change in government may come at least as much from changing Congress as electing a President. This is a good year for everyone to look very closely at all our choices (and that includes state and local government as well).
Not paid for by anyone, so no one approved this message.
Bills that will become laws originate in the House of Representatives. If passed, they move to the Senate for additional approval. If passed by the Senate, they go to the President for signature or veto. If signed into law, they are subject to challenge by affected parties who can pursue the case all the way to the Supreme court where the law can be upheld or struck down. If vetoed, the veto can be overridden by the Congress if two-thirds of both houses support the legislation. Nowhere in this process does the President have single-handed control.
Presidents, however, do exert a powerful influence. FDR did it in the depression through legislation and his "fireside chats." Reagan reinvigorated America’s sense of pride after Nixon and Carter. Bush gave us the Iraq war. Obama championed the Affordable Care Act. In the cases of FDR and Obama, Congress cooperated with the necessary legislation. This often requires that the same party control both the Office of the President and both houses of Congress (which Obama had for his first two years). Lacking control of both branches, it requires a sensible President and enough sensible members of Congress to collaborate and negotiate effective legislation - something that has been in seemingly short supply of late.
What’s this mean for the current election? Several things. If the new President and the Congress are the same party, odds of the President doing what he or she wants are higher - some of what we hear tonight may come true. Without that, gridlock may limit the President to "executive orders" (Obama’s predicament for the last six years). The new president will have the power, with the consent of Congress, to appoint new Supreme Court justices whose personal leanings will affect the interpretation and enforcement of laws for many future years. However, here again, there is a check and balance between the executive and legislative branches. The framers of the Constitution gave us a robust system for governance. All it requires are the right players. That’s why our votes matter so much, because we pick the team, not just the quarterback.
While the candidates will be looking for our votes, we must remember that much of the control of our government rests with both houses of Congress. It behoves us to scrutinize whom we will elect to Congress this year and in future years. Each individual choice for a representative or senator may not look significant, but collectively it is. Real change in government may come at least as much from changing Congress as electing a President. This is a good year for everyone to look very closely at all our choices (and that includes state and local government as well).
Not paid for by anyone, so no one approved this message.
Wednesday, June 18, 2014
What Matters Most for America - Part 1 of 5: What’s Good and What’s Not.
I am deeply dismayed by the lack of attention to the long-range items that will determine the future of our nation. In the last several decades, we have become a more polarized nation focused on divisive social issues. We have taken identities as Republicans, Democrats, or Tea Partiers and lost sight of being Americans. Because of this myopia, issues clearly on the horizon that have huge significance are getting minimal attention. The cost of this oversight may be our global preeminence.
Let’s start with the fiction that “America is the greatest country on earth.” It was, and in some areas it still is. But, this is no longer an across-the-board truth. We can no longer pat ourselves on our collective backs for our past achievements. Where are we great today and where are we losing our claim to greatness?
Our freedoms, rights as citizens, and personal protections enforced through our government are as good as or better than any nation’s. In that we can take pride. In large measure, our sense of doing right for other peoples in other nations has little parallel. When there is a global disaster, the world looks to America to lead the way. Our military strength is still far above that of any nation. We have been blessed by abundant natural resources, water, arable land, and a temperate climate (all of which we have taken for granted). Despite the great recession, we have one of the world's strongest economies. I’ve traveled the world and I am always happy to come home to the USA. It has its flaws, but on balance it is still a great place to live.
Unfortunately, that great place is eroding. Egypt, Persia, Greece, Rome, France, Spain, England, China, the Incas and the Aztecs, all peaked and declined. We could follow them into history unless we end the magical thinking that our looming problems will get solved by ignoring them. Here are some nation-sized issues that must be addressed if we are not going to slide into history as a once-great nation.
National fatness.
Mediocre educational performance.
Sustainable future energy sources.
Water resources and utilization.
Climate change and sea level rise.
Deteriorating infrastructure.
Governmental fiscal discipline.
Needs of an aging population.
Let’s start with the fiction that “America is the greatest country on earth.” It was, and in some areas it still is. But, this is no longer an across-the-board truth. We can no longer pat ourselves on our collective backs for our past achievements. Where are we great today and where are we losing our claim to greatness?
Our freedoms, rights as citizens, and personal protections enforced through our government are as good as or better than any nation’s. In that we can take pride. In large measure, our sense of doing right for other peoples in other nations has little parallel. When there is a global disaster, the world looks to America to lead the way. Our military strength is still far above that of any nation. We have been blessed by abundant natural resources, water, arable land, and a temperate climate (all of which we have taken for granted). Despite the great recession, we have one of the world's strongest economies. I’ve traveled the world and I am always happy to come home to the USA. It has its flaws, but on balance it is still a great place to live.
Unfortunately, that great place is eroding. Egypt, Persia, Greece, Rome, France, Spain, England, China, the Incas and the Aztecs, all peaked and declined. We could follow them into history unless we end the magical thinking that our looming problems will get solved by ignoring them. Here are some nation-sized issues that must be addressed if we are not going to slide into history as a once-great nation.
National fatness.
Mediocre educational performance.
Sustainable future energy sources.
Water resources and utilization.
Climate change and sea level rise.
Deteriorating infrastructure.
Governmental fiscal discipline.
Needs of an aging population.
What Matters Most for America - Part 2 of 5: Fatness and Education
Let’s begin with the old expression “fat, dumb, and happy.”
As a nation, we are fat. We lead the world in obesity - 30% of us are obese and 40% of us are overweight. Obese people get sick more often driving up the need for health care services. What’s worse, obesity is plaguing our young people. How will these people take care of the rising number of old people? Clearly, a large segment of the population follows a lifestyle that is unhealthy. We have overindustrialized our food processing. We have put too much “fast food” on every corner. We have “upsized” our serving sizes and our waistlines. We are telling ourselves that being overweight is normal. Are we nuts?
We have created a culture of “death by convenience.” How ironic is it that everyday life has become less physically demanding to the point that we must drive to a gym to burn calories by walking on a treadmill? Physical activity inherent in daily living has gone down while emotional stress has gone up. The 30% of us who have a normal weight are able to live a more “fat free” lifestyle so it can be done. While fatness is a national problem, it can only be solved by individual resolve and action. The war on fat must be fought on the home front: in the grocery store, in the kitchen, on the playground, and by exercising in the neighborhood or gym.
The dumbing down of America has been going on for some time. Part of this is illustrated in how we have managed to simplify tasks to make it easier for less-educated people to do jobs (e.g., cash registers now calculate change). The test scores of our students compared to other countries have been sliding downward. We fall in the mid range for industrialized nations. An educated populace is a cornerstone of both democracy and global competitiveness. A nation with creeping ignorance falls prey to demagogues and its internal politics veer off track. A nation with creeping ignorance is unable to do the high-tech, high-skilled jobs that provide high wages. The result is an impoverished underclass who live in an affluent society while they compete against workers earning third-world wages. Education is an enabler of success and upward economic mobility and we are struggling to make it work for us in the modern age.
Education in America has long been a local matter. Local school boards make decisions about school financing and administration. Judging school performance was often a matter of making comparisons within the county, or maybe the state. Now there are national standards. Why? Because educational performance is a key to national strength. It’s no longer good enough to be better than the state next door. We must be better than every country on earth.
Every child is unique and we need a system that identifies that uniqueness and is tailored to it. We need the fortitude and the mechanisms that advance a child when he or she has mastered material, not when he is another year older. We need two parent homes where the parents read to their kids instead of single parents working second jobs to make ends meet. We need every household to instill the educational work ethic that produces scholarship, not mere attendance. Schools cannot do what parents will not do. Education begins at home. We need a national effort to drive that point home and facilitate its happening.
We need to afford education the priority and funding that we do our defense budget, because in the 21st century, a skilled and intelligent population will be our ultimate defense. If that sounds far fetched, it’s not. The military has already had to compromise its physical and educational selection standards because of the decline in both among young people. Without skilled labor to support skilled jobs and higher pay, our economy will falter. A failing economy means weaker tax revenues which means pressure on all forms of government spending, including the military. A country whose citizenry is physically and educationally weak is militarily weak as well.
Are we happy about this? I hope not, but we seem to be almost stupified into accepting it as the status quo. At some point, the healthy and educated people are going to get tired of paying for the social benefits of the uneducated, underemployed, overweight, sickly people. We may ultimately see a societal split between the responsible have’s and the irresponsible have not’s. The have’s will want the have not’s to shape up and act responsibly. The have not’s will want the nicer homes and better incomes of the have’s and will seek to redistribute that wealth to themselves through government social programs. A nation does not lift itself up by pulling down those at the top.
As a nation, we are fat. We lead the world in obesity - 30% of us are obese and 40% of us are overweight. Obese people get sick more often driving up the need for health care services. What’s worse, obesity is plaguing our young people. How will these people take care of the rising number of old people? Clearly, a large segment of the population follows a lifestyle that is unhealthy. We have overindustrialized our food processing. We have put too much “fast food” on every corner. We have “upsized” our serving sizes and our waistlines. We are telling ourselves that being overweight is normal. Are we nuts?
We have created a culture of “death by convenience.” How ironic is it that everyday life has become less physically demanding to the point that we must drive to a gym to burn calories by walking on a treadmill? Physical activity inherent in daily living has gone down while emotional stress has gone up. The 30% of us who have a normal weight are able to live a more “fat free” lifestyle so it can be done. While fatness is a national problem, it can only be solved by individual resolve and action. The war on fat must be fought on the home front: in the grocery store, in the kitchen, on the playground, and by exercising in the neighborhood or gym.
The dumbing down of America has been going on for some time. Part of this is illustrated in how we have managed to simplify tasks to make it easier for less-educated people to do jobs (e.g., cash registers now calculate change). The test scores of our students compared to other countries have been sliding downward. We fall in the mid range for industrialized nations. An educated populace is a cornerstone of both democracy and global competitiveness. A nation with creeping ignorance falls prey to demagogues and its internal politics veer off track. A nation with creeping ignorance is unable to do the high-tech, high-skilled jobs that provide high wages. The result is an impoverished underclass who live in an affluent society while they compete against workers earning third-world wages. Education is an enabler of success and upward economic mobility and we are struggling to make it work for us in the modern age.
Education in America has long been a local matter. Local school boards make decisions about school financing and administration. Judging school performance was often a matter of making comparisons within the county, or maybe the state. Now there are national standards. Why? Because educational performance is a key to national strength. It’s no longer good enough to be better than the state next door. We must be better than every country on earth.
Every child is unique and we need a system that identifies that uniqueness and is tailored to it. We need the fortitude and the mechanisms that advance a child when he or she has mastered material, not when he is another year older. We need two parent homes where the parents read to their kids instead of single parents working second jobs to make ends meet. We need every household to instill the educational work ethic that produces scholarship, not mere attendance. Schools cannot do what parents will not do. Education begins at home. We need a national effort to drive that point home and facilitate its happening.
We need to afford education the priority and funding that we do our defense budget, because in the 21st century, a skilled and intelligent population will be our ultimate defense. If that sounds far fetched, it’s not. The military has already had to compromise its physical and educational selection standards because of the decline in both among young people. Without skilled labor to support skilled jobs and higher pay, our economy will falter. A failing economy means weaker tax revenues which means pressure on all forms of government spending, including the military. A country whose citizenry is physically and educationally weak is militarily weak as well.
Are we happy about this? I hope not, but we seem to be almost stupified into accepting it as the status quo. At some point, the healthy and educated people are going to get tired of paying for the social benefits of the uneducated, underemployed, overweight, sickly people. We may ultimately see a societal split between the responsible have’s and the irresponsible have not’s. The have’s will want the have not’s to shape up and act responsibly. The have not’s will want the nicer homes and better incomes of the have’s and will seek to redistribute that wealth to themselves through government social programs. A nation does not lift itself up by pulling down those at the top.
What Matters Most for America - Part 3 of 5: Energy, Water, and Climate Change
We are complacent about our energy supplies. We rely on fossil fuels for much of our energy. Every time there is a shortage of supply, we worry about energy. As soon as that particular situation resolves, we become complacent again. The advent of fracking to release natural gas, and the discovery of more oil beneath North Dakota, make it easy to feel comfortable today. The inescapable truth is that hydrocarbons are ultimately finite. Eventually they will be used up. It may take 100 years, but the day will come when the last oil well runs dry and the last gas well sputters out. The nation that prepares for that day will be the one that survives into the post hydrocarbon future. Long-term energy sufficiency is a strategic national issue. Only nuclear and renewable sources of energy will be available in the long run. We must increase these sources of energy and develop more efficient ways of using energy to match both supply and demand. It takes a national research and development effort to do so.
Just as energy is finite, so is water. We get that water from three sources: rainfall, groundwater, desalinization. Rainfall is irregular from year-to-year. Droughts can appear and last a decade or longer. The entire climate can swing through long cycles. While we have studied nature to see how the climate has changed over thousands of years, we only have records for a few hundred years. Climate and weather are complex systems that we are just beginning to understand. We tend to think that climate is a fixed feature of life, like the shoreline of an ocean. It is not. In a country that has been “settled” for less than 200 years, we have only a limited exposure to the climate swings possible in North America. How climate change will affect our rainfall and water supply is very much up in the air. We need to prepare for adversity, not prosperity. How climate is affecting Australia is worth noting because their present may be our future.
Lurking below the surface is a major water problem. We have been pumping groundwater out of our Midwestern aquifers faster than it is being replenished. We have been drawing down mother nature’s water savings account faster than she can make deposits. One of these days, those water wells will run dry. When that happens, a large section of America’s breadbasket will no longer be able to produce food as it does today. Less food and a larger population are not a good combination. A similar situation is occurring in California where winter snow accumulations are insufficient to supply water demands for agriculture and a growing population. How much of this problem is random or cyclical versus permanent is hard to know, but that is no reason to delay action. We need a long-term plan and investment in our infrastructure to ensure our water supplies and control their usage.
Climate change is an issue where opinions are divided, but not rationally so. To borrow from a famous historical document, “We hold these truths to be self-evident...” Hundreds of millions of years ago, nature sequestered carbon from the atmosphere into the bodies of plants and animals that were covered by sediments and compressed into coal or converted to oil and natural gas. This process took tens of millions of years. In a matter of a few hundred years, we will have released back into the atmosphere a significant portion of this stored carbon through the burning of fossil fuels. We are messing with mother nature. We have raised the carbon dioxide level in the atmosphere to what is considered to be a tipping point. That tipping point is where the earth enters a global warming cycle that will melt glaciers and the polar ice cap releasing more water into the oceans and exposing more ocean to the sun’s heat creating a self-sustaining rise in temperature. Once the snowball starts melting, we can’t stop it.
There is no debate that the greenhouse effect of CO2 gas is real. While the earth has gone through numerous cycles of warming and cooling (e.g., the ice age about 15,000 years ago) without man being the cause, it is foolish to ignore the impact of man’s activity on the planet. Regardless of what a person believes is the cause, the effect is the same - rising temperatures, rising ocean levels, agricultural disruption, and population migration. We face a crisis in coastal communities where millions of people may be forced to relocate as water levels rise. It will change housing, transportation, insurance costs, and personal fortunes as real estate literally goes underwater. The time to plan and prepare is now.
Just as energy is finite, so is water. We get that water from three sources: rainfall, groundwater, desalinization. Rainfall is irregular from year-to-year. Droughts can appear and last a decade or longer. The entire climate can swing through long cycles. While we have studied nature to see how the climate has changed over thousands of years, we only have records for a few hundred years. Climate and weather are complex systems that we are just beginning to understand. We tend to think that climate is a fixed feature of life, like the shoreline of an ocean. It is not. In a country that has been “settled” for less than 200 years, we have only a limited exposure to the climate swings possible in North America. How climate change will affect our rainfall and water supply is very much up in the air. We need to prepare for adversity, not prosperity. How climate is affecting Australia is worth noting because their present may be our future.
Lurking below the surface is a major water problem. We have been pumping groundwater out of our Midwestern aquifers faster than it is being replenished. We have been drawing down mother nature’s water savings account faster than she can make deposits. One of these days, those water wells will run dry. When that happens, a large section of America’s breadbasket will no longer be able to produce food as it does today. Less food and a larger population are not a good combination. A similar situation is occurring in California where winter snow accumulations are insufficient to supply water demands for agriculture and a growing population. How much of this problem is random or cyclical versus permanent is hard to know, but that is no reason to delay action. We need a long-term plan and investment in our infrastructure to ensure our water supplies and control their usage.
Climate change is an issue where opinions are divided, but not rationally so. To borrow from a famous historical document, “We hold these truths to be self-evident...” Hundreds of millions of years ago, nature sequestered carbon from the atmosphere into the bodies of plants and animals that were covered by sediments and compressed into coal or converted to oil and natural gas. This process took tens of millions of years. In a matter of a few hundred years, we will have released back into the atmosphere a significant portion of this stored carbon through the burning of fossil fuels. We are messing with mother nature. We have raised the carbon dioxide level in the atmosphere to what is considered to be a tipping point. That tipping point is where the earth enters a global warming cycle that will melt glaciers and the polar ice cap releasing more water into the oceans and exposing more ocean to the sun’s heat creating a self-sustaining rise in temperature. Once the snowball starts melting, we can’t stop it.
There is no debate that the greenhouse effect of CO2 gas is real. While the earth has gone through numerous cycles of warming and cooling (e.g., the ice age about 15,000 years ago) without man being the cause, it is foolish to ignore the impact of man’s activity on the planet. Regardless of what a person believes is the cause, the effect is the same - rising temperatures, rising ocean levels, agricultural disruption, and population migration. We face a crisis in coastal communities where millions of people may be forced to relocate as water levels rise. It will change housing, transportation, insurance costs, and personal fortunes as real estate literally goes underwater. The time to plan and prepare is now.
What Matters Most for America - Part 4 of 5: Infrastructure, Fiscal Discipline, and the Aging Population
The infrastructure of the country is deteriorating. We have enjoyed the benefits of an interstate highway and air transportation system that are barely more than 50 years old. Our sewer and water systems are older. These things are the underpinnings of modern commerce and living. They are decaying. Just as we can enjoy a new house without making repairs for years, we have enjoyed the benefits of these new modes of transportation. Unless we reinvest in updating and upgrading them, we will be living with a century-old infrastructure that will break down leaving us gridlocked and uncompetitive. Maintenance isn’t glamorous, just necessary. We need to reinvest in the shared assets that make America run. Most of these are managed by government.
The imbalance of spending versus tax revenue and the resulting growth in deficits and total debt for the United States is a festering long-term problem. Fiscal collapse is an intangible issue. Unlike easily seen potholes in a deteriorating highway, fiscal rot only is visible on an accounting ledger. Governments can get away with spending beyond their means longer than individuals, but not forever. As spending for social programs (Social Security, Medicare, Affordable Care Act) increases with an increasing older population and the additional of new beneficiaries, the pressure to continue deficit spending will continue.
We are funding the present by borrowing from the future. The big problem with that future is the number of people available to pay the bill relative to those getting benefits is going in the wrong direction. It is a very tough decision to make, but to provide at least a minimal safety net for the most vulnerable, government spending must be curtailed. There are hard fiscal priorities that we must determine and live by. Financial responsibility has to become our government’s top priority, otherwise all its other programs cannot be sustained. The government may not go out of business, but it may inflate its way out of trouble by paying old debts with cheaper, inflated dollars. It saves itself at the expense of its citizens by using inflation as a hidden form of taxation. It’s time to “Just Say No” to about 30% of today’s spending and to say “Yes” to about a 10% increase in taxation in order to balance our budget and reduce our debt. We have been fiscally lazy and paying the price only gets more costly with each passing day.
The aging population is a problem that we have seen coming for a long time. It was once a long-range problem that is now becoming a current problem. As the baby boomers enter their golden years, the costs for Social Security and Medicare will rise. Demands on the health care system will increase when the number of medical professionals may actually shrink. Alzheimer’s patients requiring constant care will increase. And, because many seniors have not managed their finances sufficiently to prepare for retirement, demands for increases to Social Security are likely to arise. There may come a time when America wishes its old people would just die because they cost too much to keep alive.
We need to develop today more economical ways for seniors to live and to get inexpensive health care. We need to prepare for a society where, instead of the kids moving back in with the parents, the parents are moving back in with the kids. We need to determine how health care dollars will be allocated so that we spend less on end-of-life treatments in order to fund care for active lives. A healthy workforce is more essential to the nation than healthy retirees. In the future, we will come face-to-face with an inter generational conflict for health care services and benefits. It will force us to look at euthanasia as an option for those beyond medical help. Such a debate will rival that of abortion and take many years to resolve. The time to begin that discussion is now.
The imbalance of spending versus tax revenue and the resulting growth in deficits and total debt for the United States is a festering long-term problem. Fiscal collapse is an intangible issue. Unlike easily seen potholes in a deteriorating highway, fiscal rot only is visible on an accounting ledger. Governments can get away with spending beyond their means longer than individuals, but not forever. As spending for social programs (Social Security, Medicare, Affordable Care Act) increases with an increasing older population and the additional of new beneficiaries, the pressure to continue deficit spending will continue.
We are funding the present by borrowing from the future. The big problem with that future is the number of people available to pay the bill relative to those getting benefits is going in the wrong direction. It is a very tough decision to make, but to provide at least a minimal safety net for the most vulnerable, government spending must be curtailed. There are hard fiscal priorities that we must determine and live by. Financial responsibility has to become our government’s top priority, otherwise all its other programs cannot be sustained. The government may not go out of business, but it may inflate its way out of trouble by paying old debts with cheaper, inflated dollars. It saves itself at the expense of its citizens by using inflation as a hidden form of taxation. It’s time to “Just Say No” to about 30% of today’s spending and to say “Yes” to about a 10% increase in taxation in order to balance our budget and reduce our debt. We have been fiscally lazy and paying the price only gets more costly with each passing day.
The aging population is a problem that we have seen coming for a long time. It was once a long-range problem that is now becoming a current problem. As the baby boomers enter their golden years, the costs for Social Security and Medicare will rise. Demands on the health care system will increase when the number of medical professionals may actually shrink. Alzheimer’s patients requiring constant care will increase. And, because many seniors have not managed their finances sufficiently to prepare for retirement, demands for increases to Social Security are likely to arise. There may come a time when America wishes its old people would just die because they cost too much to keep alive.
We need to develop today more economical ways for seniors to live and to get inexpensive health care. We need to prepare for a society where, instead of the kids moving back in with the parents, the parents are moving back in with the kids. We need to determine how health care dollars will be allocated so that we spend less on end-of-life treatments in order to fund care for active lives. A healthy workforce is more essential to the nation than healthy retirees. In the future, we will come face-to-face with an inter generational conflict for health care services and benefits. It will force us to look at euthanasia as an option for those beyond medical help. Such a debate will rival that of abortion and take many years to resolve. The time to begin that discussion is now.
What Matters Most for America - Part 5 of 5: Who Will Act?
Who will address these issues?
National fatness.
Mediocre educational performance.
Sustainable future energy sources.
Water resources and utilization.
Climate change and sea level rise.
Deteriorating infrastructure.
Governmental fiscal discipline.
Needs of an aging population.
It isn’t likely to be the politicians to whom we entrust the leadership of our nation. The political parties might rise to the occasion and champion some of these issues if they weren’t so busy worrying about fund raising and the next election cycle and how to stymie the efforts of the other party. With this level of leadership for government, the bureaucracy below may send up warning signals, but isn’t likely to act on its own. Government is fiddling while the country heads toward multiple crises. The nature and scale of those crises are such that the government’s typical crisis management problem solving will be inadequate to handle them. We will be overwhelmed.
It is not likely to be the capitalists. Capitalism has no national allegiance. It’s driving force is the creation of wealth for the owners of the capital. To the extent that individual capitalists have a sense of national pride and concern, they will guide their industries to help America. Unfortunately, most large corporations are global enterprises with institutional stockholders. Because of this, there is no driving force to make a firm an “American company” looking out for our national interests. Small businesses may have patriotic positions, but they lack the leverage needed to command the stage and move the country. We can compare this situation in America with that of China. In China, business, industry, and government are coordinated as a single national force. It may not produce the quality of personal life and liberty that the American system does, but it is making China a more effective international competitor for trade and resources. As the Chinese economy gets larger and is fueled by its own domestic demand, it will become less dependent on exports to America, more self-confident as a nation, and militarily stronger. It will challenge America for world dominance. It will be helped down that road by capitalism that sold it the technology it needed to overtake America.
Only we, the citizens, can get these issues addressed. For some issues, this will be done by individual action in our personal lives. For other issues, we must copy the special interest groups who lobby the legislatures and finance political campaigns to get what they want. They seem to have the influence that makes the system work. The problem is getting everyday people to band together to work on these long-range issues when we are confronted by so many near-term problems in our personal lives. Only when groups dedicated to solving long-range problems get involved in the political process, by preparing and financially supporting worthwhile candidates, can action begin. It happens now for near-term and emotional issues like gun control and abortion. While those are meaningful, they won’t mean much in a country that fails to address its larger problems. In the meantime, the clock ticks on toward our days of reckoning.
National fatness.
Mediocre educational performance.
Sustainable future energy sources.
Water resources and utilization.
Climate change and sea level rise.
Deteriorating infrastructure.
Governmental fiscal discipline.
Needs of an aging population.
It isn’t likely to be the politicians to whom we entrust the leadership of our nation. The political parties might rise to the occasion and champion some of these issues if they weren’t so busy worrying about fund raising and the next election cycle and how to stymie the efforts of the other party. With this level of leadership for government, the bureaucracy below may send up warning signals, but isn’t likely to act on its own. Government is fiddling while the country heads toward multiple crises. The nature and scale of those crises are such that the government’s typical crisis management problem solving will be inadequate to handle them. We will be overwhelmed.
It is not likely to be the capitalists. Capitalism has no national allegiance. It’s driving force is the creation of wealth for the owners of the capital. To the extent that individual capitalists have a sense of national pride and concern, they will guide their industries to help America. Unfortunately, most large corporations are global enterprises with institutional stockholders. Because of this, there is no driving force to make a firm an “American company” looking out for our national interests. Small businesses may have patriotic positions, but they lack the leverage needed to command the stage and move the country. We can compare this situation in America with that of China. In China, business, industry, and government are coordinated as a single national force. It may not produce the quality of personal life and liberty that the American system does, but it is making China a more effective international competitor for trade and resources. As the Chinese economy gets larger and is fueled by its own domestic demand, it will become less dependent on exports to America, more self-confident as a nation, and militarily stronger. It will challenge America for world dominance. It will be helped down that road by capitalism that sold it the technology it needed to overtake America.
Only we, the citizens, can get these issues addressed. For some issues, this will be done by individual action in our personal lives. For other issues, we must copy the special interest groups who lobby the legislatures and finance political campaigns to get what they want. They seem to have the influence that makes the system work. The problem is getting everyday people to band together to work on these long-range issues when we are confronted by so many near-term problems in our personal lives. Only when groups dedicated to solving long-range problems get involved in the political process, by preparing and financially supporting worthwhile candidates, can action begin. It happens now for near-term and emotional issues like gun control and abortion. While those are meaningful, they won’t mean much in a country that fails to address its larger problems. In the meantime, the clock ticks on toward our days of reckoning.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

